Skip to Main Content

Review Types

This guide will help you get started with determining which type of review is right for you and your research project.

Outline of Strategies

Timeframe: depends on the size and scope of the review

Question: unlike other reviews, a literature review is framed around a topic rather than a specific question. Researchers should identify the focus and scope of the review they intended to write

Research protocol: not required although the researcher may benefit from creating one to help stay focused and organized

Search: may or may not include comprehensive searching

Appraisal: may or may not include quality assessment

Synthesis: typically narrative

Analysis: there are number of different ways that the reviewer can formulate their analysis of the available literature. The analysis may be chronological, conceptual, thematic, etc.

Traditional vs Narrative Literature Reviews

There is a lot confusion that surrounds the concept of a literature review. And for good reason. There isn't necessarily one way to write a literature review. In fact, there are at least four different options:

  • General literature review: a review of the most important and critical aspects of the current knowledge of the topic. The type of literature review can either be a standalone paper or component of a larger study, thesis, or dissertation.
  • Theoretical literature review: examines the how theory shapes or frames research
  • Methodological literature review: describes methods and design. These types of reviews outline the strengths and weakness of the methods uses and provide recommendations for future use.
  • Historical literature review: examines research throughout a period of time, often beginning at the starting point of an issue, concept, or theory. The goal of these reviews is to frame research in a historical context to show familiarity with contemporary development and to suggest direction of future research.

Regardless of type, a literature review should still strive to be a comprehensive, critical, and objective analysis of the existing and current knowledge on a given topic. 

Adapted from Charles Sturt University Library: Literature Review: Traditional or Narrative Literature Reviews.