Skip to Main Content

Writing & Publishing

Identify and Evaluate Journals

When it comes to creating a list of target journals for your publication, consider two main factors: the scope and reputation of the journal. Remember that impact factor is just one measure of reputation – there are others such as the size of readership, the authors that publish within that journal, how specialized it is, and the reputation of the editorial board. There are other criteria to look at once you have identified some target journals – these can be found on the next tab.

It is vital to honestly assess the importance of your research and its impact – you don’t want to waste your time submitting to journals that won’t publish your work because of mismatch.

So, how do you begin? Start with what you have already read! It is likely that you have a cache of articles from your research and literature review that are similar to the one that you are writing – look at the journals in which they were published!  Additionally, use your network of colleagues to see if they have experience with the journals in question. If needed, conduct supplementary literature searches (ASK A LIBRARIAN for assistance) to identify other journals.

There are resources on the final tab in this box to further assist in identifying journals.

  • What is the scope of the journal? Do the subjects/topics covered in the journal match your work.
    • Does the journal publish the type of article you want to publish, e.g. systematic review, RCT, etc?
  • Reputation of the journal.
  • Are you or your colleagues familiar with the journal?
    • Be sure to look at its publisher's information, its editorial board, and the authors who have previously published with it.
  • If the journal is marketed as being peer reviewed, what is the review process?
  • Are there length restrictions on an article? 
  • Who is your target audience? Does it match with the journal's target audience? 
  • Does the journal provide author guidelines or information for authors? Is the information easy to find/access?
  • What are the journal's policies on copyright ownership?
  • Is the journal indexed in a database that you use? e.g. PubMed, Scopus, Directory of Open Access Journals (DOAJ).
  • Does the journal have an ISSN, and do article have DOIs
  • Turnaround time for publication.
  • Are there fees to publish with the journal? Is the journal transparent with the fees prospective authors are expected to pay?

Where to search

Tools for Finding a Journal for Publication

Tools to help you find the journal that best matches your needs. Enter the title of your manuscript and/or its abstract. The journal finders will generate a list of relevant titles.

Journal Directories