Skip to Main Content

Mathematics & Statistics

Primary v Secondary

Primary versus Secondary Research Scientific Research is conducted and submitted for publication  Primary source Published peer-reviewed articles Structured format may include: Abstract Introduction Materials and methods Results Discussion Cited references Literature cited Which is Reported in the news or Literature review Secondary source Newspapers Magazines Published articles – review article New York Times logo USA Today logo Time Magazine cover thumbnail

Popular v Scholarly

Popular vs. Scholarly Literature “Scholarly and “popular” are terms used to describe a source’s content, purpose, audience and more.  Popular sources are useful for getting ideas for a topic or for background and anecdotal information. Typically, however, you should support your arguments by citing scholarly articles, which contain original research written by experts. Popular: General interest stories and opinion pieces Easily understood language Not peer-reviewed Rarely give bibliographic citations Not structured format Examples include time Magazine, Discover, U. S. News, the Boston Globe, the New York times, USA Today. Secondary sources usually fall into this category. Scholarly: Original research and inquiry Scholarly or technical language Often peer-reviewed Includes full citations for sources Structured format Examples include Blood, American Journal of Psychology, American Journal of Economics and Sociology, and the Journal of Finance. Primary sources usually fall into this category.

Peer-Review Process

Peer Review Process This is a continuing cycle. Author writes article and submits to journal. Editor sends copy to peers (experts in the field) for reviewing.  This is usually a blind process.  The peer reviewers check the manuscript for accuracy and assess the validity of the research methodology and procedures.  Their goal is to find any gaps in reasoning and to ensure nothing has been overlooked. The article is returned to the editor along with recommendations to either reject, revise, or accept it. The editor sends the article back to the author along with the reviewers’ feedback and requests for revisions.  After the article is revised it will have to be resubmitted for publication. Paper accepted and published, then usually listed in databases for other researchers to find and read, to inform their writing.  Back to Author writes article and submits to journal.  The cycle continues.