First Year Writing

Primary Sources Vary by Discipline

Primary sources vary by discipline.

In history, primary sources are original records that provide firsthand evidence to understand a historical event or period.  

In literature, primary sources are the original texts (e.g., novels, short stories, plays, etc.).  

In the arts, primary sources are original works of art or music.  

In the natural or social sciences, the results of an experiment or study are typically found in scholarly articles or conference papers; these articles and papers that present original results are considered primary sources.

Original Articles vs Review Articles

It can be difficult to tell the difference between original research articles and review articles. You can use this chart to help you.

You can also read the article abstract for clues. If you see phrases such as "we tested"  and "in our study, we measured", it will tell you that the article is reporting on original research.

Tertiary Sources

What is a tertiary source?

Tertiary sources are condensed versions of information, compiled from primary and secondary sources. Think of it as a summary that doesn't add new analysis or interpretation.

What are some examples of tertiary sources?

  • Encyclopedias
  • Dictionaries
  • Bibliographies
  • Handbooks
  • Almanacs
  • Wikipedia
  • Most "Reference" Books

How should you use tertiary sources?

  • Starting Point: Use them to get oriented on a new topic and identify relevant keywords.
  • Finding Sources: Bibliographies in tertiary sources can lead you to valuable primary and secondary sources.
  • Background Knowledge: They're handy for brushing up on your general understanding before diving into more complex research.
  • Not for Direct Citation: They don't offer in-depth analysis, unique insights or original research, so citing them directly weakens your work.

Primary Sources

What is a primary source?

A primary source is firsthand information created at the time of the event or topic being studied or a firsthand account of an event later recalled by an eyewitness. Think of it as the raw material of history or research.

What are some examples of primary sources?

  • diaries, journals & letters
  • autobiographies & memoirs
  • period newspapers (factual accounts)
  • original research studies and experiment results
  • government publications (i.e. Census data, economic statistics, etc.)
  • data sets & survey data
  • speeches
  • interviews with event participants or witnesses (i.e. oral histories)
  • photographs and posters created at the time
  • works of art (paintings, drawings, sculptures) created at the time
  • works of literature, film, and music created at the time
  • proceedings of meetings, conferences and symposia
  • internet communications, i.e. emails, listservs, etc.

How should you use primary sources?

  • Gain New Perspectives: Primary sources, like diaries, letters, or interviews, offer the perspectives of people who lived through or witnessed the event. This can reveal unexpected biases, emotions, and details that enrich your understanding.
  • Corroborate or Challenge Existing Scholarship:  Primary sources allow you to see the raw evidence for yourself. You can compare it to existing scholarship and identify areas where it aligns or contradicts established narratives.
  • Develop Critical Thinking Skills: Primary sources often come with ambiguities and complexities. Analyzing them requires critical thinking. You'll need to consider the author's background, purpose, potential biases, and context of creation to interpret the information accurately.
  • Craft Compelling Arguments:  By drawing insights directly from primary sources, you can add depth and originality to your research. It allows you to showcase your ability to analyze evidence and build arguments based on firsthand accounts.

Secondary Sources

What is a secondary source?

A secondary source analyzes, discusses and interprets primary sources. They are materials that have been created AFTER an event has happened.

What are some examples of secondary sources?

  • biographies
  • articles in scholarly journals that interpret or review PREVIOUS findings
  • popular magazine articles
  • a textbook on a specific subject
  • book reviews
  • book of critical essays

How should you use secondary sources?

  • Understand Different Perspectives: Scholarly articles and critical analyses can present various viewpoints on a topic, helping you develop a well-rounded understanding.
  • Find Primary Sources: Secondary sources often reference the primary source they're based on, which can lead you to the original research or firsthand accounts.
  • Develop a Research Question: By reading how others have analyzed a topic, you can identify gaps in knowledge and refine your own research question.

Serials

Journals, magazines, and newspapers are serial publications that are published on an ongoing basis.

Many scholarly journals in the sciences and social sciences include primary source articles where the authors report on research they have undertaken. Consequently, these papers may use the first person ("We observed…"). These articles usually follow a standard format with sections like "Methods," "Results," and "Conclusion."

In the humanities, age is an important factor in determining whether an article is a primary or secondary source. A recently-published journal or newspaper article on the Brown v. Board of Education Supreme Court case would be read as a secondary source, because the author is interpreting an historical event. An article on the case that was published in 1955 could be read as a primary source that reveals how writers were interpreting the decision immediately after it was handed down.

Serials may also include book reviews, editorials, and review articles. Review articles summarize research on a particular topic, but they do not present any new findings; therefore, they are considered secondary sources. Their bibliographies, however, can be used to identify primary sources.

So, what is it?

Identifying primary & secondary sources

When looking at a resource to determine whether it is primary or secondary, words that describe the action of the author can be helpful. For example,  words like these can indicate actual research carried out:

  • examined
  • predicted
  • experimented
  • tested
  • investigated
  • explored

In secondary resources, since the focus is on analyzing or discussion of a primary source, you would look for words that describe the action of the author indicating that this is an analysis or discussion, such as:

  • analysis
  • synthesis
  • overview
  • appraisal
  • reported on

You will need to examine the abstract and/or the article to determine if the resource is primary or secondary. While the words above can help indicate the type of resource, this is not a cut and dried process where if you see a particular word, that means the resource is always primary.

Locating a findings section in an article doesn't mean the source is either primary or secondary. Check to see whether the authors did the research themselves, or whether they analyzed research done by others.

 

https://academicguides.waldenu.edu/library/evaluating/sources

How do you know if a scholarly article is primary?

A primary research article reports on an empirical research study conducted by the authors. It is almost always published in a peer-reviewed journal.

This type of article:

  • Asks a research question or states a hypothesis or hypotheses
  • Identifies a research population
  • Describes a specific research method
  • Tests or measures something
  • Includes a section called "method" or "methodology." This may only appear in the article, not the abstract.
  • Includes a section called "results."

Words to look for as clues include: analysis, study, investigation, examination, experiment, numbers of people or objects analyzed, content analysis, or surveys.

A question to ask yourself when trying to identify primary or secondary sources is:

Did the person writing the thing do the thing?

While this may sound odd, the best indicator that something is a primary source is if the author of the piece actually DID the work that led to the creation of the resource.